PLUM 3 Results
The Third Tournament of the 1998-99 Season of the
Parliamentary League of the Upper Midwest
November 17, 1998
5 SCHOOLS, 14 TEAMS, OPEN DIVISION ONLY
PARTICIPATING SCHOOLS:
- Bethany Lutheran College, Mankato MN
- Bethel College, St. Paul MN
- Gustavus Adolphus College, St. Peter MN
- Macalester College, St. Paul MN
- St. Olaf College, Northfield MN
Preliminary Rounds:
- 3 - 0 Macalester MB (Micah Minnema - Josh Beu)
- 3 - 0 St. Olaf GO (Rob Grace - Matt Ober)
- 2 - 1 Macalester RR (Nikki Ruklic - Niloy Ray)
- 2 - 1 Macalester WA (Katie Weitz - Mike Aschenbrener)
- 2 - 1 Bethany Lutheran OP (Leah Olson - Amy Proeber)
- 2 - 1 Macalester / Bethany Lutheran DB (Roland DuCote - Melinda Buck)
- 2 - 1 Bethany Lutheran SH (Dan Schneider - Heather Hagen)
- 1 - 2 Bethany Lutheran LH (Jon Loging - Mike Hefti)
- 1 - 2 Gustavus Adolphus CK (Lindsay Carlson - Andy Knudson)
- 1 - 2 Macalester WH (Sherman Wu - Diedre Hipwell)
- 1 - 2 Bethany Lutheran HC (Sandy Hultgren - Racheal Crissinger)
- 1 - 2 Bethel BH (Danielle Barry - Scott Hagley)
- 0 - 3 Gustavus Adolphus SC (Gaurav Sharma - Joe Carlile)
- 0 - 3 Bethel MP (Laura McDonnell - Heidi Post)
Bronze Round:
- Macalester RR (opp) def. Bethany SH 1-1 (and tiebreaker)
- Macalester WA (opp) def. Bethany OP 2-0
- Macalester MB (opp) def. Bethany LH 2-0
- St. Olaf GO (gov) def. Macalester/Bethany DB 1-1 (and tiebreaker)
Gold Round:
- Macalester RR and Macalester OP closeout
- Macalester MB (opp) def St. Olaf GO 2-0

Gold award winners from Macalester: Micah Minnema and Josh Beu

Top 5 speakers:
front: Matt Ober, Jon Loging
back: Nikki Ruklic, Niloy Ray, Josh Beu
INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS (top 10):
- 1 Jon Loging, Bethany
- 2 Niloy Ray, Macalester
- 2 Matt Ober, St. Olaf
- 2 Josh Beu, Macalester
- 5 Nikki Ruklic, Macalester
- 6 Lindsay Carlson, Gustavus
- 6 Katie Weitz, Macalester
- 8 Mike Aschenbrener, Macalester
- 8 Joe Carlile, Gustavus
- 10 Roland DuCote, Macalester
- 10 Micah Minnema, Macalester
TOPICS:
- Round One: This house believes that diet-watching is overrated.
- Round Two: This house would require every college student to possess a laptop computer.
- Round Three: This house prefers amateur politicians.
- Bronze Round: This house prefers alternative medicine.
- Gold Round: This house would pluck the roses before they wither.
Most recent update 17 November 1998
Send comments or suggestions to tkuster@blc.edu