PLUM 10.3 Results

The Third Tournament of the Tenth (2006-2007) Season of the
Parliamentary League of the Upper Midwest
November 21, 2006

4 SCHOOLS, 13 TEAMS, OPEN DIVISION ONLY

PARTICIPATING SCHOOLS:

Preliminary Rounds:

Bronze Round:

Gold Round:


Bethany Lutheran College's Gold Award winners: David Buchs and Lisa Buchs


Bethany Lutheran College's Gold Award winners: Jesse DeDeyne and Nina Maksymenko


Top speakers: Maus, Gad, Chaudhary, Pothapragada, DeDeyne, Buchs

INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS (top 12 of 26):

TOPICS:

Round 1: This house believes that the danger of terrorism is overstated.

Round 2: This house would bring back the military draft.

Round 3: (case) Sheriff Rodgers is the sheriff of Plum County and is up for re-election. He has been sheriff for 8 years and has done a good job. This election he is running against one of his deputies. While his deputy does a decent job, Sheriff Rodgers is concerned that he would not make a good sheriff. Recently the deputy failed his sergeant's exam for the second time, which means Sheriff Rodgers could not promote him. Now the deputy is looking for a promotion from the people. The deputy has lived in the county all his life and has a lot of family living in the county. He has started a campaign pointing out all the nit-picky things that have gone wrong in the county and Sheriff Rodgers feels he is losing support. His deputy's exams are technically part of his personnel record, but it has a direct bearing on the job he is running for. He is concerned that people will think less of him for keeping a person on staff who has failed the test twice. He also doesn't want to win because of an "attack" campaign.

In this case the Government team must support the statement: Sheriff Rodgers is morally justified to disclose his deputy's exam record.

Bronze Round: This house would deceive the press.

Gold Round: This house would offer Thanksgiving dinner to all Americans.


Most recent update 21 November 2006
Send comments or suggestions to logman@blc.edu