PLUM 10.2 Results

The Second Tournament of the Tenth (2006-2007) Season of the
Parliamentary League of the Upper Midwest
October 10, 2006

4 SCHOOLS, 14 TEAMS, OPEN DIVISION ONLY

PARTICIPATING SCHOOLS:

Preliminary Rounds:

Bronze Round:

Gold Round:


University of Minnesota Gold Award winners: Daryl Pinto and Dave Watson


Bethany Lutheran College's Gold Award winners: Jesse DeDeyne and Nina Maksymenko


Top speakers: DeDeyne, Knewtson, Cunningham, Birk, Watson

INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS (top 13 of 28):

TOPICS:

Round 1: This house would appease North Korea.

Round 2: This house prefers potential over kinetic.

Round 3: (case) Rob works with Mark at an ad agency. The two are good friends and Mark's wife is pregnant with their second child. Mark recently was given a large client that it is obvious he cannot handle. While Mark is a good man, he doesn't have the skill or experience to deal with the client and the rest of his work. Due to a change in upper management, a review of all personnel has been going on to see where personnel can be cut. Rob knows Mark will be reviewed soon and if things don't improve for Mark, he will be let go. Rob also knows that Mark is in over his head. But Rob too is challenged by his workload, and he doesn't know if he himself will be on the chopping block. Mark asks Rob for help with his client. Rob knows he can help Mark, but is afraid he might take on more than he can handle in order to help.

In this case the Government team must defend the position: Rob is morally obligated to help Mark.

Bronze Round: Resolved: the Republicans have forfeited their right to govern.

Gold Round: This house would arm teachers.


Most recent update 10 October 2006
Send comments or suggestions to logman@blc.edu