PLUM 8.4 Results

The Fourth Tournament of the Eighth (2004-2005) Season of the
Parliamentary League of the Upper Midwest
February 1, 2005

5 SCHOOLS, 15 TEAMS, OPEN DIVISION ONLY

PARTICIPATING SCHOOLS:

Preliminary Rounds:

Bronze Round:

Gold Round:


South Dakota State University's Gold Award winners: Aaron Rahlfs and Robert Haar


Gustavus Adolphus College's Gold Award winners: Brandon Gillette and Becky Kuehl


Top speakers: Henry Stokman, Brandon Gillette, Jacob Plovanic, Casey Barnes (Laura Watkins missing)

INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS (top 20 of 30):

TOPICS:

Round 1: This House prefers the bullet to the ballot.

Round 2: This House would try celebrities in secret.

Round 3: (Case) Tom Myers is on a full music scholarship to his university because of his mastery of the violin. However, he is failing his freshman algebra class. He is working hard in the class, but he doesn't understand the material. This is a required class for graduation and he needs to maintain a good GPA to keep his scholarship. His instructor, Prof. Dixon, has worked with Tom on many occasions. He knows Tom has been working hard and realizes the impact a failing grade will have on Tom's future. Knowing Tom will spend the rest of his life playing the violin, Prof. Dixon has an idea. If Tom attends every class session and works as hard as he can on all his assignments, Prof. Dixon thinks Tom should deserve a C for the course, even if he actually fails the class.

In this case, the Government must defend the position: Prof. Dixon is morally correct allowing Tom to pass his algebra class.

Bronze: This House would burn the flag.

Gold: This House would resurrect the dream of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.


Most recent update 2 February 2005
Send comments or suggestions to tkuster@blc.edu