PLUM6.2 results

PLUM 6.2 Results

The Second Tournament of the Sixth (2002-2003) Season of the
Parliamentary League of the Upper Midwest
October 8, 2002

9 SCHOOLS, 26 TEAMS, OPEN DIVISION ONLY

PARTICIPATING SCHOOLS:

Bethany Lutheran College, Mankato, MN
Bethel College, St. Paul, MN
Gustavus Adolphus College, St. Peter, MN
Macalester College, St. Paul, MN
Minnesota State University, Mankato, MN
St. Cloud State University, St. Cloud, MN
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN
University of St. Thomas, Minneapolis, MN
University of Wisconsin, River Falls, WI

Preliminary Rounds:

3 - 0 Bethel HB (Jeidi Holm - Katrisa Bohne)
3 - 0 Gustavus Adolphus RG (Jay Reding - Brandon Gillette)
3 - 0 Bethany Lutheran BL (Casey Barnes - Stacy Lilienthal)
3 - 0 Gustavus Adolphus GP (Greg Gorham - Justin Paul)
2 - 1 Bethany Lutheran CH (Vlad Cherevko - Marie Holtz)
2 - 1 Bethany Lutheran PS (Martina Putirkova - Jon Schmidt)
2 - 1 Bethel MJ (Steven McMullen - Terilyn Johnston)
2 - 1 Bethel SJ (Luke Scripter - Jason Jenkins)
2 - 1 Gustavus Adolphus DK (Kari DenOtter - Kim Kautzer)
2 - 1 Macalester WM (Raphael Whitford - Aaron Mitchell)
2 - 1 Minnesota State/St. Cloud State KB (Nick Kennedy - Brian Billings)
2 - 1 St. Thomas HK (Becky Harris - Dominika Kuzlak)
2 - 1 Minnesota/Macalester DM (Morris Dupree - Patrick Miller)
2 - 1 Minnesota RI (Anthony Reel - Hafidz Ismail)
1 - 2 Bethany Lutheran KK (Shawna Kopp - Larry Kovaciny)
1 - 2 Bethany Lutheran HM (Adam Holtz - Jeff Merseth)
1 - 2 Wisconsin River Falls RR (Gabe Redmond - Jeff Rutkowski)
1 - 2 Wisconsin River Falls JS (Amber Johnson - Erin Swenson)
1 - 2 Wisconsin River Falls DG (Luke Duffney - Jessica Gavin)
1 - 2 Bethany Lutheran QB (Tricia Quist - Jeff Bukowski)
1 - 2 Bethany Lutheran MW (Patti Manteufel - Eric Wood)
0 - 3 Wisconsin River Falls AW (Daniel Auge - Nick Wilson)
0 - 3 Wisconsin River Falls GE (Kelly Gipson - Terri Ellman)
0 - 3 Wisconsin River Falls BB (Giacomo Baglio - Jessica Berg)
0 - 3 Wisconsin River Falls SJ (Ty Sims - Jennifer Jasinski)
0 - 3 Wisconsin River Falls BK (Denise Baker - Ashley Kocak)

Bronze Round:

Advancing Directly to the Gold Round: Bethel HB and Gustavus Adolphus RG
- Minnesota/Macalester DM (opp) def. Bethany Lutheran PS 2-0
- Bethany Lutheran BL (opp) def. Gustavus Adolphus DK 2-0
- Macalester WM (opp) def. Gustavus Adolphus GP 2-0
- Minnesota RI (opp) def. Bethany Lutheran CH 2-0
- Bethel SJ (opp) def. St. Thomas HK 2-0
- Minnesota State/St. Cloud State KB (opp) def. Bethel MJ 3-0

Gold Round:

Bethany Lutheran BL (gov) def. Bethel SJ 2-1
Macalester WM (opp) def. Bethel HB 3-0
Gustavus Adolphus RG (opp) def. Minnesota/Macalester 2-1
Minnesota State/St. Cloud State (opp) def. Minnesota RI 2-1

Macalester's Gold Award winners: Raphael Whitford and Aaron Mitchell

Gold Award winners from Gustavus Adolphus: Brandon Gillette and Jay Reding

Gold Award winners: Brian Billings, St. Cloud State, and Nick Kennedy, Minnesota State

Gold Award winners from Bethany Lutheran: Stacy Lilienthal and Casey Barnes

4 of 5 top speakers: Greg Gorham, Jon Schmidt, Luke Scripter, Katrisa Bohne

INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS (top 24):

1 - Larry Kovaciny - Bethany Lutheran
2 - Jon Schmidt - Bethany Lutheran
3 - Luke Scripter - Bethel
4 - Greg Gorham - Gustavus Adolphus
5 - Katrisa Bohne - Bethel
6 - Casey Barnes - Bethany Lutheran
7 - Jay Reding - Gustavus Adolphus
7 - Brandon Gillette - Gustavus Adolphus
7 - Jeff Rutkowski - Wisconsin River Falls
10 - Stacy Lilienthal - Bethany Lutheran
11 - Marie Holtz - Bethany Lutheran
12 - Martina Putirkova - Bethany Lutheran
13 - Heidi Holm - Bethel
14 - Brian Billings - St. Cloud State
15 - Steven McMullen - Bethel
16 - Jason Jenkins - Bethel
17 - Becky Harris - St. Thomas
18 - Gabe Redmond - Wisconsin River Falls
19 - Nick Wilson - Wisconsin River Falls
20 - Jessica Berg - Wisconsin River Falls
21 - Anthony Reel - Minnesota

TOPICS:

ROUND 1: This house would make punishment more harsh.
ROUND 2: Those who are not for us are against us.
ROUND 3: Dylan should give away his fortune to charities.
Case: Dylan is the only heir of a wealthy family. Just after receiving his inheritance, he discovers that the fortune originally came from a grandfather who obtained it in illegal and unscrupulous ways - exploiting poor workers, corrupting public officials, savaging the environment. Dylan is troubled about the source of his fortune. The Government Team must defend this proposition: Dylan should give away his fortune to charities.
BRONZE: America's golden age of culture still lies ahead.
GOLD: Winning is not as important as how you play the game.

Most recent update 10 October 2002
Send comments or suggestions to tkuster@blc.edu